LAWYER: If Cops Say “I Smell Alcohol” – Say THESE WORDS

.
.

The Importance of Protecting Your Rights During a DWI Stop: A Comprehensive Guide

Getting pulled over for a suspected Driving While Intoxicated (DWI) charge can be a nerve-wracking experience. Often, drivers find themselves in a situation where their actions can significantly impact the outcome of the encounter with law enforcement. In this article, we’ll explore the crucial steps you should take during a DWI stop, how you can protect your rights, and why staying silent is often the best strategy.

Understanding the Initial Encounter

Imagine you’re driving home from a nice dinner, feeling fine, when you spot the flashing lights in your rearview mirror. The officer walks up to your car and says the five words that can ruin your night: “I think I smell alcohol.” At this point, most people are inclined to explain themselves, perhaps saying something like, “I only had one drink” or “I had dinner hours ago.” However, making this mistake is the single most common error that people make during a DWI stop.

Why the “I Smell Alcohol” Statement Is a Trap

One of the key phrases used by police officers is “I smell alcohol.” This statement is not an observation, it’s a trap. Alcohol itself does not have a smell. The only thing that has a scent is the beverage that contains alcohol, and even then, it may be faint. Officers know that they are using a specific interrogation technique that has been taught to them at the police academy.

When an officer says, “I think I smell alcohol,” what they’re really doing is creating an opportunity for you to incriminate yourself. How? Because most drivers will try to explain themselves. You might tell the officer, “I only had one drink,” or “I’m fine, I ate dinner hours ago.” These responses, while well-intentioned, are not a defense but rather an admission. You’re inadvertently providing the officer with evidence that can be used against you in court.

Every word you say is being recorded and cataloged. When you volunteer information, such as the number of drinks you had or the time you ate, the officer can use that information to calculate your blood alcohol concentration (BAC) and make a stronger case against you. In essence, you are handing them the case on a silver platter.

How to Respond to “I Smell Alcohol”

So, what should you do when an officer says, “I smell alcohol”? The key is to stay calm and exercise your constitutional rights. Here’s the script that you should memorize and use in every situation:

“Officer, I exercise my constitutional right not to answer questions about what I’ve had to eat or drink. Am I free to go, or am I being detained?”

This simple yet effective response is the best way to protect yourself during a DWI stop. Let’s break down why this works:

Your Right to Remain Silent

Your Right to Know Whether You Are Free to Go

Politeness and Cooperation

What to Do If the Officer Presses Further
If the officer tries to push you for more answers, saying things like, “If you’ve got nothing to hide, just tell me what you drank,” you can respond with the following:

“Officer, I once again exercise my constitutional right to remain silent, and I will not answer any further questions until my lawyer is present.”

This line is a powerful tool because your refusal to answer questions based on your constitutional right cannot be used as evidence against you. Officers may try to get you to confess, but by standing firm in your rights, you can prevent them from using your words against you.

Field Sobriety Tests: Voluntary, Not Mandatory

Many people believe that they have no choice but to perform field sobriety tests when asked by the officer. However, under the Supreme Court ruling in Pennsylvania v. Mims, cops can require you to step out of your vehicle, but you do not have to take the field sobriety tests. These tests are voluntary in every state, and here’s why that matters:

You could be stone-cold sober and still fail these tests. For instance, the walk-and-turn test, where you must walk nine steps heel to toe, turn, and walk back. If you start before the officer says “go,” or if you misstep, you could fail the test, even if you’re perfectly sober.

When an officer asks you to perform field sobriety tests, you have every right to decline. Politely tell the officer:

“Officer, I only agree to perform these tests with my attorney present after the opportunity to seek counsel.”

By doing this, you maintain your rights and avoid the potential pitfalls of a test that could be used against you, even if you’re sober.

The Key to Protecting Your Rights

By following these steps, you significantly reduce the risk of being wrongfully arrested for DWI. The most important thing to remember is that silence is often your best defense. You are not obligated to speak to the officer beyond what is required by law, and anything you say can and will be used against you in court.

Additionally, be polite, respectful, and assertive when invoking your rights. The more cooperative you appear, the more difficult it becomes for the officer to claim you were uncooperative. By sticking to the script, you can ensure that you are protecting your rights and making it more difficult for the officer to build a case against you.

Conclusion

DWI stops are routine for law enforcement, but they can be life-altering for drivers. By understanding your rights and knowing exactly what to say, you can protect yourself from making critical mistakes during these encounters. If you ever find yourself in this situation, remember the script, stay calm, and don’t allow yourself to be manipulated into saying anything that could hurt your case. Your constitutional rights are there for a reason, and by exercising them properly, you can make the officer’s job much harder and protect your freedom.