Brock Purdy vs. Patrick Mahomes: A Statistical Breakdown Over the Last Year

In the world of the NFL, it’s almost sacrilegious to compare any quarterback to Patrick Mahomes, widely regarded as the league’s best. However, over the last year, a surprising name has emerged as a statistical competitor to Mahomes: Brock Purdy, the San Francisco 49ers quarterback. While some may brush off this comparison, the numbers tell an interesting story.

FULL VIDEO:

Statistical Comparison: Purdy Leading Key Categories

Both Purdy and Mahomes share identical 14-6 records over the last year, but Purdy’s performance in several key metrics has surpassed Mahomes. For instance, Purdy has thrown for 5,441 yards, eclipsing Mahomes’ 5,087 yards by nearly 400. Purdy also boasts a superior touchdown-to-interception ratio, recording 36 touchdowns and 13 interceptions compared to Mahomes’ 33 touchdowns and 19 interceptions.

Even in more nuanced categories, Purdy shines. He leads the league in yards per attempt (9.6 vs. Mahomes’ 7.1) and passer rating (111.3 vs. 92.1). These numbers alone suggest that Purdy’s contribution to his team’s offense is on par with, if not exceeding, Mahomes’ during this period.

Team Dynamics: The Supporting Cast Argument

Critics often argue that Purdy benefits from a superior supporting cast, referring to the talented roster around him as “Yak gods” (yards after catch). However, an interesting statistic reveals that Purdy ranks at the bottom of the league in YAC from his receivers, meaning his numbers aren’t padded by his teammates. Instead, Purdy leads the league in air yards, proving he’s excelling through his own ability to push the ball down the field, not merely relying on short passes that his receivers turn into big gains.

On the other hand, Mahomes has no shortage of offensive support either. The Kansas City Chiefs boast one of the best offensive lines in the NFL, and Mahomes is consistently aided by Travis Kelce, the league’s premier tight end. This suggests that both quarterbacks have solid supporting casts, making the comparison between Purdy and Mahomes even more valid.

Purdy’s Evolution: From Good to Elite?

Since taking over as the 49ers’ quarterback, Purdy has quietly transitioned from being a solid starter to one of the most efficient quarterbacks in the league. His ability to read defenses, make smart decisions, and push the ball downfield are all traits of a quarterback on the verge of becoming elite. Yet, the key to solidifying Purdy’s status as elite will be consistency.

Consistency is often cited as the true measure of greatness in the NFL. Purdy has shown this for the past two and a half years, but as the speaker in the original transcript points out, he still has to maintain this level over a longer period to fully enter the elite conversation.

A Path to Greatness

The 2024 season will be crucial in determining Purdy’s standing among the NFL’s elite quarterbacks. If he continues to play at this high level throughout the season, it’s hard to argue against him reaching that elite tier. His ability to create beyond the X’s and O’s, coupled with his growth in confidence and execution, makes him a quarterback to watch closely as the season progresses.

Conclusion: Is Purdy Elite Yet?

While Purdy may not have the star power or highlight-reel plays of Mahomes, his numbers over the last year indicate he’s quietly rising to the top of the NFL. Whether he can maintain this level of play consistently will determine whether he can truly claim a spot among the league’s best. But for now, Purdy has proven that he’s not just a product of a great system—he’s a quarterback in his own right, one whose play is inching closer to elite status.

The 2024 season will be Purdy’s proving ground, and if he continues at this rate, fans and analysts alike will have no choice but to recognize him as one of the best in the league.