LAWYER: Say THESE WORDS When Cops Claim They Have a Warrant

.
.

How to Protect Your Rights When Cops Show Up with a Warrant

When law enforcement officers knock on your door claiming they have a warrant, your mind can easily go into overdrive. Panic sets in as you wonder, do they really have a warrant? Can they come in without showing it to you? What should you say or do to protect your rights without making the situation worse?

Understanding the legal processes surrounding warrants and the rights you have is crucial when dealing with police encounters. A warrant does not give police unlimited power, and how you handle the situation can significantly impact whether your rights are protected or violated. In this article, we will discuss the essential steps you should take when police show up with a warrant, how to identify whether they have a valid warrant, and the exact phrases that can protect your rights.

What is a Legal Warrant?

The Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution guarantees the right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures. It says, “The right of the people to be secure against unreasonable searches, and no warrant shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.”

In simpler terms, for a warrant to be valid, it must meet three critical criteria:

Probable Cause: The police must have real, verifiable facts showing that a crime may have been committed. It cannot just be a hunch.
Particularity: A warrant must specify exactly what is being searched for and where it will be searched. For example, police cannot search your entire home just because they have a warrant. It has to be specific.
Oath or Affirmation: Whoever is providing the information for the warrant must swear that the facts are true under penalty of perjury.

A valid legal warrant is a safeguard against unwarranted government intrusion, but that doesn’t mean it can’t be abused.

How Police Abuse the Warrant System

While a warrant is supposed to protect your rights, sometimes the system is exploited. Cops may cut corners when applying for warrants, fake oaths, or judges may rubber-stamp warrants without reading them thoroughly. These lapses in the system have led to innocent people being arrested, their homes destroyed, and their lives turned upside down.

The Case of Michael Mendenhall: Hearsay Warrant

In one example, a business owner named Michael Mendenhall in Denver, Colorado, was arrested based on hearsay. A trespasser claimed that Mendenhall threatened him with a bat, but the officer who filed the warrant never verified the accusation. The detective didn’t interview the accuser, and instead, he filed the information as fact, swore to it in the affidavit, and presented it to a judge. Without any real evidence, the judge signed the warrant, and Mendenhall’s home was raided.

The police found a bat in Mendenhall’s house, but it turned out to be a commemorative item. Charges were dropped within 72 hours, but Mendenhall spent a night in jail and suffered damage to his reputation. This situation exemplifies how the system can fail. The police did not check the facts, the detective didn’t do his job properly, and the judge didn’t ask any questions before signing the warrant.

The Case of Avery Marshall: Lying to Get a Warrant

In another case, police in rural North Carolina lied to a judge in order to obtain a warrant. They claimed that a phone pinged near the residence of Avery Marshall and Alyssa Carr, whom they believed were involved in car theft. However, the cops didn’t mention that the phone pinged over a large area and could have come from multiple homes. They also misled the judge by stating that the couple’s vehicle matched the one of the alleged suspect, which was untrue.

The police executed the raid, throwing flash grenades and pointing rifles at the family, but no suspect was found. The charges were eventually dropped, but the damage had already been done. The family was traumatized, their home was destroyed, and the raid was based on lies. This case highlights the serious consequences of poorly executed warrants and dishonest behavior by law enforcement.

How to Protect Yourself When Cops Claim They Have a Warrant

So, what should you do if cops come to your door with a warrant? The key is to know your rights and exercise them wisely. Below are the essential steps you should take to protect yourself.

1. Ask to See the Warrant

The first and most important step is to ask to see the warrant. It’s as simple as saying, “Officer, do you have a warrant? If so, I’d like to see it.” By doing this, you force the officers to produce the actual warrant. If they can’t show it to you, they have no right to enter your home. If they do show you the warrant, check to ensure it’s valid.

A valid warrant should be signed, specific, and meet the criteria outlined above. If they claim they have a warrant but don’t have it to show you, you can either ask them to slide it under the door or place it against the window for you to view. Never open the door until you’ve seen the warrant.

2. Do Not Consent to a Search

Even if the cops have a warrant, you must still protect your rights. State clearly that you do not consent to a search of anything in your home. By saying this, you make it clear that you are only allowing them to search what is specifically listed in the warrant. If they go beyond the scope of the warrant, you can challenge their actions later.

For example, if the warrant says they are looking for a weapon, but they start searching your personal belongings or your phone, you can say, “I do not consent to a search of this area.” By saying this, you create a legal boundary that will help protect your rights if the search goes beyond the warrant’s terms.

3. Exercise Your Right to Remain Silent

If the cops start questioning you, remember you have the right to remain silent. Politely say, “I exercise my right to remain silent. I demand my lawyer.” This will protect you from self-incrimination. Even innocent answers to questions can be twisted or misinterpreted, so it’s better to stay quiet and consult a lawyer.

4. Document Everything

Documenting everything is vital. Take notes of everything that happens: the time the cops arrived, what they said, what they searched, and what they took. If they damage your property, take photos of the damage. You can also record the encounter if it is safe to do so. Keep track of the officers’ badge numbers and names, and try to get the names of any witnesses present.

By recording everything, you create a paper trail that can be used as evidence later if the cops violate your rights. If they raid your home, make sure to get an inventory of all the items they seize, as this will help you assess if any items were taken illegally.

5. Consider Filing a Civil Rights Lawsuit

If your rights were violated during the search, you may have a case for a civil rights lawsuit. Under 42 U.S.C. Section 1983, you can file a lawsuit against law enforcement for violating your constitutional rights. This is especially important if the police raided the wrong house, lied to get the warrant, or went beyond the scope of the warrant.

In the case of the Kansas newspaper raid mentioned earlier, where police used a warrant to punish the newspaper for exposing the mayor’s corruption, the family sued and won. They held the officers accountable for their actions, and the case set an important precedent for holding police officers accountable for violating citizens’ rights.