Ilhan Omar Sparks Fury After Comparing Stephen Miller to Nazis During Clash Over Somali Immigrant Crackdown
WASHINGTON — Representative Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.), a prominent member of the progressive “Squad,” has ignited a heated debate after drawing a provocative comparison between Trump advisor Stephen Miller’s immigration rhetoric and Nazi propaganda. The comments came during her appearance on CBS News’ “Face the Nation” on Sunday, as she responded to escalating criticism and enforcement actions targeting Minnesota’s Somali-American community.
Omar’s Comments and Miller’s Immigration Stance
Omar, a first-generation Somali immigrant, lambasted Miller—who is Jewish and widely known as the architect of President Trump’s hardline immigration policies—for espousing “white supremacist rhetoric.” She said, “When I think about Stephen Miller and his white supremacist rhetoric, it reminds me of the way the Nazis described Jewish people in Germany.”
The statement was prompted by Miller’s recent post on X (formerly Twitter), where he warned against mass migration, claiming, “You are not just importing individuals. You are importing societies. No magic transformation occurs when failed states cross borders. At scale, migrants and their descendants recreate the conditions, and terrors, of their broken homelands.”
Miller has long faced accusations from progressive critics who link his immigration views to white supremacism, despite his Jewish heritage.
The Minnesota Context: Fraud Scandal and Federal Crackdown
Omar’s remarks are set against the backdrop of a $1 billion fraud scandal in Minnesota, where dozens of individuals—many from the Somali-American community—allegedly misappropriated taxpayer funds intended for social services. The scandal, known as the Feeding Our Future fraud, has drawn national scrutiny and fueled a wave of criticism from Trump and his allies.
President Trump recently lashed out at Omar and Somali-Americans, calling them “garbage” and blaming them for “complaining” and “doing nothing” for the country. “When they come from hell, and they complain and do nothing but bitch, we don’t want them in our country,” Trump said during a cabinet meeting.
Following Trump’s remarks, ICE ramped up enforcement operations in Minnesota, raising concerns among immigrant advocates about the targeting of Somali communities.
Omar’s Response: Warning Against Dehumanization
Omar condemned Trump’s comments as “completely disgusting,” emphasizing that the president was dehumanizing American citizens. “It’s also really important for us to remember that this kind of hateful rhetoric and this level of dehumanizing can lead to dangerous actions by people who listen to the president,” she said.
She also defended Minnesota’s response to the fraud scandal, arguing that the rapid rollout of COVID-19 relief programs left insufficient safeguards and oversight, which allowed the fraud to spiral out of control.
Miller’s Perspective and Ongoing Investigation
Stephen Miller, speaking on Fox News’ “Hannity,” described the Minnesota fraud as “the single greatest theft of taxpayer dollars, through welfare fraud, in American history,” promising that further revelations would “shock the American people.”
The Bigger Picture: Rhetoric, Responsibility, and Public Safety
The exchange between Omar and Miller highlights the deep divisions in American politics over immigration, accountability, and the boundaries of public discourse. Omar’s comparison to Nazi Germany underscores her concern about the dangers of dehumanizing language, while Miller and Trump maintain that their criticisms are rooted in concern for public safety and fiscal responsibility.
As investigations into the Minnesota fraud continue and federal enforcement intensifies, the debate over who belongs in America—and how leaders should talk about immigrants—remains fiercely contested.
