All-Star Snub Stuns WNBA: Alanna Smith Left Out, NBA Legend Big Shaq Demands Recount Over Caitlin Clark Controversy
In a stunning twist that has left fans and analysts in disbelief, Alanna Smith — one of the WNBA’s most consistent and impactful performers this season — has been completely left off the 2025 All-Star roster. The move has sparked backlash across social media, and now, an NBA icon is speaking out.
Shaquille O’Neal — aka “Big Shaq,” the four-time NBA champion and basketball legend — is calling foul.
“Alanna Smith deserved that All-Star spot. No way around it,” Shaq declared in a heated segment on Inside the NBA.
“If we’re picking based on who’s playing the best ball — she’s in. Period. She’s been better than Caitlin Clark these past few weeks. That’s the truth.”
Dominating — But Ignored?
Alanna Smith has been a breakout star this WNBA season, putting up impressive stats while serving as a defensive anchor and consistent offensive weapon. Her hustle, versatility, and basketball IQ have not only led her team to crucial wins but also earned the respect of coaches and players around the league.
So when the All-Star rosters were announced without her name — fans were left stunned.
“This doesn’t make sense,” one analyst tweeted. “She’s outplaying players who did get selected. What are we even rewarding anymore — skill or spotlight?”
Shaq: “This Is A Popularity Contest, Not A Performance Award”
Never one to bite his tongue, Shaq went even further in his critique:
“Let’s be real — some of these selections are about clicks, not buckets,” he said.
“Caitlin Clark is a huge name, I get it. She brings ratings. But this is the All-Star Game, not a popularity poll. If you watch the games — and I do — Alanna’s playing better basketball right now. Full stop.”
He ended with a bold suggestion:
“We need a recount. Or better yet — an honest system that values performance over fame.”
Fans Rally Behind Smith
Social media has erupted in support of Alanna Smith, with hashtags like #JusticeForAlanna and #FixTheAllStarVotes climbing the trending charts. Thousands of fans are echoing Shaq’s sentiments, accusing the league of ignoring players who are less marketable but more deserving.
Even several WNBA players and coaches have subtly thrown shade at the All-Star selection process, hinting that something feels “off” this year.
Clark Caught in the Storm
Unsurprisingly, Caitlin Clark — the most-voted player in this year’s All-Star pool — has found herself in the middle of the backlash. While Clark has had her fair share of impressive performances, critics say her selection is driven more by media hype than on-court dominance.
“This isn’t about dragging Clark,” one fan posted. “She’s good — but she’s not the only one who’s good. And right now, Alanna Smith is outplaying her.”
Clark has not responded publicly to the controversy, but pressure is mounting on the WNBA to address the growing frustration.
Will the League Respond?
As the All-Star Game draws near, the heat is turning up. Will the WNBA defend its selection process? Will they allow late additions to correct public outcry? Or will Alanna Smith be forced to watch the game from the sidelines despite having one of the strongest seasons of any forward in the league?
One thing’s certain: Big Shaq has entered the chat — and he’s not backing down.
“I know what greatness looks like,” Shaq said. “And Alanna Smith? That’s greatness. Give her her spot.”
Let’s see if the league listens — or lets the firestorm rage on.
