How One Pilot’s “CRAZY” Landing Method Cut Carrier Crashes by 80%
.
.
On a foggy morning in Portsmouth Harbor on November 16, 1951, Captain Dennis Campbell stepped aboard the HMS Illustrious, clutching a simple diagram in his briefcase. This unassuming sketch, depicting a flight deck angled 10° to port, seemed innocuous at first glance. Yet, unbeknownst to him, it would soon become a pivotal innovation in naval aviation, saving countless lives.
The Grim Reality of Naval Aviation
Captain Campbell was acutely aware of the dire situation facing naval aviators. In the previous year alone, the Royal Navy had lost 43 aircraft due to landing accidents, resulting in 17 fatalities and numerous injuries. Each loss occurred during the critical final moments of flight—when a 30-ton jet, hurtling toward the deck at 140 mph, attempted to catch an arresting wire while a steel barricade loomed just 60 feet ahead. The statistics were alarming. The US Navy faced an even bleaker reality, with 776 class A mishaps reported in 1951, translating to more than two accidents per day.
The Korean War exacerbated the crisis. Carriers like the USS Boxer and USS Princeton reported multiple barrier crashes, leading to devastating losses. The introduction of jet aircraft had transformed naval aviation, but the existing carrier designs were woefully inadequate. Pilots found themselves trapped in a deadly cycle—committed to landing with engines spooled up, unable to abort if they missed the wires. The mathematics of landing were unforgiving. A Panther jet landing at 125 knots covered 211 feet per second, leaving just 2.1 seconds to react if the wires were missed.
A Desperate Need for Change
The traditional straight deck carriers were designed for slower propeller-driven aircraft that could easily throttle back and land safely. However, the new jet engines required pilots to maintain power until touchdown, creating an untenable situation. The crash barriers, designed to catch aircraft that missed the wires, often failed, leading to catastrophic results. Captain Bruce Williams witnessed the horror firsthand when a barrier failure resulted in the deaths of 11 men aboard the USS Kearsarge.
Despite numerous attempts to improve the situation—stronger barriers, alternative landing surfaces—nothing proved successful. The accident rate continued to rise, and the need for a radical solution became increasingly urgent. It was in this environment of despair and desperation that Captain Campbell’s unconventional idea began to take shape.
The Spark of Innovation
While most experts focused on improving existing systems, Campbell had a different thought: Why did the landing area have to be parallel to the ship’s axis? If the landing area could not be extended, perhaps it could be widened by angling the deck. On a train ride from Portsmouth to London, Campbell sketched his idea—a flight deck angled 10° to port. This simple adjustment would allow pilots who missed the wires to throttle up, climb away, and attempt another landing without the threat of a barricade or parked aircraft.
On August 7, 1951, Campbell presented his concept to a room full of senior naval officers and engineers. The reaction was immediate and dismissive. “That is completely illegal,” one commander declared. The room erupted in disbelief, with many insisting that the idea was not only impractical but dangerous. Yet, amidst the skepticism, one engineer, Lewis Bodington, saw potential. He suggested testing the concept with a painted outline on HMS Triumph’s flight deck.
Testing the Angled Deck
The trials began in September 1951, with pilots making simulated touch-and-go approaches on the painted angled deck. To everyone’s surprise, the anticipated drift problem never materialized. Instead, pilots discovered a newfound sense of freedom. Lieutenant Peter Chilton, one of the test pilots, later recalled, “For the first time in my career, I wasn’t terrified. I just poured on power and climbed away.” The results were undeniable: the angled deck provided a safety net that straight decks simply could not offer.
As the tests continued, the US Navy took notice. Lieutenant Commander Eric Brown, a distinguished British test pilot, presented the findings to American pilots, urging them to consider the implications of Campbell’s design. Despite initial resistance, the evidence was compelling. The US Navy agreed to conduct parallel tests on the USS Midway.
A Historic Transformation
By January 12, 1953, Lieutenant Commander Harold Buell was ready to make his first landing on the USS Antietam’s newly installed angled deck. As he approached the carrier, he felt a mix of anxiety and hope. This was a moment that could change everything. When he missed the wires, instead of panic, he remembered the training: throttle up and go around. For the first time, he felt the weight of fear lift from his shoulders. He was not facing a barricade; he had a second chance.
Over the next 60 days, the data was irrefutable. The carrier air group made over 1,300 landings with zero crashes or injuries. The implementation of the angled deck led to a staggering reduction in landing accidents and fatalities. The statistics told a powerful story: before the angled deck, the US Navy faced an average of 647 class A mishaps per year, with landing accidents accounting for 52% of all losses. After the change, those numbers dropped dramatically.
Legacy of a Visionary
Captain Dennis Campbell’s innovation transformed naval aviation forever. By the late 1950s, every major aircraft carrier in the Western world had adopted the angled deck design. Even the Soviets, initially resistant, implemented the concept after a series of catastrophic accidents.
Despite this monumental achievement, Campbell remained humble. He never sought fame or recognition for his role in changing naval aviation. After retiring from the Royal Navy in 1960, he worked as a technical consultant, always prioritizing pilot safety above accolades. When he passed away in 2000, his obituary acknowledged his contribution to aviation, but it failed to capture the profound impact he had on countless lives.
Lieutenant Colonel Arthur Black, a Marine Corps pilot, encapsulated the sentiment of many when he wrote to Campbell’s family, thanking them for the second chances he had received because of Campbell’s refusal to accept the status quo.
Conclusion
The story of Captain Dennis Campbell is a testament to the power of innovation born from compassion and courage. His simple sketch not only redefined carrier operations but also saved thousands of lives. It serves as a reminder that sometimes, the most profound changes come from those who dare to challenge the norms and fight for what is right. In the world of naval aviation, Campbell’s legacy will forever be etched in the skies, a beacon of hope for future generations of pilots.
