The Macabre Case of the Twins Who Married Each Other and Created Their Own Dynasty (Oregon, 1903)

.
.

In the remote mountains of Oregon, where dense trees block the sunlight even at midday, there lies a chilling tale about the Oats family—one that locals whisper about but seldom discuss openly. This story, which began in the isolated community of Crater Lake in 1903, reveals the depths of human depravity and the lengths to which a family will go to protect their darkest secrets.

The Oats Family

Waldo Oats, a hardworking yet reserved man, had purchased his sprawling 200-acre property in 1885, dreaming of building a timber empire. After the tragic death of his wife during childbirth in 1884, he was left to raise his twin children, Phoebe and Wilbert, alone. The family was isolated, living three miles from their nearest neighbors, and their lives revolved around the sawmill Waldo operated on their land.

Phoebe and Wilbert were peculiar children, with almost white-blonde hair and piercing blue eyes. From a young age, they shared an unusual bond, often finishing each other’s sentences and communicating in a silent language that excluded everyone else. Their isolation intensified after an incident in 1895, when Phoebe was ridiculed by other children in town for her paleness and shyness. Enraged by the treatment of his daughter, Waldo decided that the family would have little to do with the outside world.

A Disturbing Decision

As the twins grew older, Waldo noticed increasingly strange behaviors. They spent hours locked in the attic, developing a silent communication that unnerved him. When they turned 18, Waldo discovered that they had made plans to marry each other—not to outsiders, but to each other. This shocking revelation stemmed from their twisted belief that preserving their lineage through consanguinity was a way to maintain their family’s uniqueness.

Despite Waldo’s vehement protests, the twins held their wedding ceremony in May 1903, with Waldo reluctantly serving as a witness. Following the ceremony, the twins transformed their home into a fortress, installing locks and covering windows, all while Waldo grew more isolated and troubled by their increasingly bizarre behavior.

The Birth of Secrets

As months passed, the twins began preparing for a family of their own. When Phoebe became pregnant, Waldo felt a sense of dread. The child was born in March 1904 with visible deformities, and rather than expressing concern, the twins were fascinated by the child’s uniqueness. This marked the beginning of a chilling pattern; they treated their deformed child with obsessive care while neglecting their second child, who appeared normal.

The twins’ obsession with their children deepened as they continued to isolate themselves from the world. They made strange purchases in town, stockpiling supplies as if preparing for a long period of seclusion. Waldo, increasingly disturbed by the sounds coming from the basement and the twins’ erratic behavior, began to suspect that something was terribly wrong.

The Hunter’s Curiosity

Homer Mixon, an experienced hunter, became suspicious of the Oats property after noticing unusual activity. He visited the twins, who welcomed him but raised his suspicions further. The house smelled medicinal and was oddly quiet, with no sign of the children he knew had been born. During his visit, he heard the unmistakable sound of a child crying from the basement, but when he mentioned it, the twins dismissed his concerns with cold indifference.

Determined to uncover the truth, Homer began observing the property from a distance. He noticed strange patterns and lights at odd hours, and his growing suspicion turned into a need for answers. Unfortunately, his curiosity would cost him dearly.

The Disappearance

Homer’s second visit to the Oats property would be his last. He approached the house stealthily, peering through a basement window. What he saw shattered his understanding of humanity. The basement was divided into sections, each containing evidence of confinement. The twins were keeping their children as if they were specimens in a twisted experiment. Horrified, Homer realized he had stumbled upon a dark secret that would seal his fate.

Three days later, when Homer didn’t return from his planned hunt, a search was organized. His rifle was found abandoned in the forest, but there was no trace of him. The twins feigned concern, but their eyes betrayed a chilling confidence. Rumors began to circulate about the Oats family, and whispers of danger spread through the community.

A Growing Nightmare

As the years passed, Waldo’s health deteriorated, and the twins continued to isolate themselves further. They had more children, each born under increasingly disturbing circumstances. The twins meticulously documented their children’s development, treating them as mere subjects of observation rather than human beings. They referred to their children by numbers rather than names, indicating a complete detachment from parental love.

Dr. Clarence Benson, a local physician, became alarmed when he noticed discrepancies in the number of children born to the Oats family. His investigation led him to suspect that the twins were hiding something sinister. However, like Homer, he would never return from his inquiry.

The Sheriff’s Investigation

By 1913, Sheriff Skyler Tucker could no longer ignore the mounting pressure from the community regarding the Oats property. Armed with a search warrant, he and his deputies approached the house, which now seemed more like a prison than a family home. The twins greeted them with unsettling calm.

Inside, Tucker discovered the horrifying truth. The house was filled with notes documenting the twins’ cruel experiments on their own children. In the basement, he found the remains of a child, and the surviving children were in deplorable conditions, malnourished and traumatized. The twins had conducted their twisted observations without a shred of remorse, believing they were advancing scientific knowledge.

The Aftermath

The trial of Phoebe and Wilbert Oats shocked the community. The twins were found guilty of murder and child abuse, yet they maintained that their actions were justified. Waldo, who had been found in a state of mental collapse, never recovered from the trauma of discovering the horrors that had unfolded in his home.

The surviving children were placed in specialized care, but their chances of recovery were grim. The Oats property was abandoned, and its dark legacy lingered in the air. The house eventually burned down, leaving behind only whispers of the atrocities committed within its walls.

A Haunting Legacy

The legend of the Oats twins serves as a chilling reminder of the darkest aspects of human nature. It compels us to confront the uncomfortable truth that the most profound horrors often arise not from external forces, but from within ourselves. The twins’ story is a testament to the dangers of isolation and the capacity for evil that can flourish in the absence of empathy.

As the wind whispers through the ancient trees of Oregon, the echoes of the Oats property remind us to remain vigilant against the shadows that may lurk in the forgotten corners of our world.