This 1899 photo of two sisters looks peaceful — until you notice what one of them is holding

.
.

The Hidden Truth of Hannah and Grace

In January 2021, Dr. Marcus Chen stood in the climate-controlled archive room of the Library of Congress, staring at a photograph that would change his understanding of American history forever. The image, dated 1899, depicted two young Black women seated side by side in a studio, dressed in elegant white blouses and dark skirts, their hair styled in the popular Gibson girl fashion. At first glance, it appeared to be a typical portrait, a moment of peace captured in time. But as Marcus examined it more closely, he felt a sense of unease creeping in.

The older sister, perhaps 20 years old, gazed defiantly into the camera, her posture rigid and her expression resolute. The younger sister, 18, sat with her hands folded, but there was tension in her demeanor. Something about their expressions suggested they were bracing for something ominous, and Marcus couldn’t shake the feeling that this was more than just a simple photograph.

As he flipped the photograph over, he noticed the stamp of the Hartwell Portrait Studio in Lexington, Kentucky, along with a handwritten note that simply read, “The sisters, October 1899.” Intrigued but puzzled, Marcus flagged the image for high-resolution scanning, hoping that modern technology might reveal details hidden to the naked eye.

Three weeks later, he sat at his computer, coffee in hand, ready to examine the digital file. As he zoomed in on the image, his heart raced. The backdrop was typical of the era, but it was the younger sister’s lap that caught his attention. At 50 times magnification, he discovered a small dagger, carefully concealed between her fingers, its blade glinting in the light. This revelation sent chills down his spine. Why did these young women need a hidden weapon? What were they protecting themselves from?

Determined to uncover their story, Marcus began his investigation by researching the Hartwell Portrait Studio. Founded by Edmund Hartwell, the studio had a unique reputation for serving clients regardless of race—a rarity in the segregated South. This led Marcus to wonder if Hartwell had kept records of his Black clients that other studios might have ignored.

After contacting the Lexington Public Library, Marcus learned that they held a collection of Hartwell’s business records, including appointment books. When he examined the entries for October 1899, he found a note indicating a portrait sitting for two subjects, marked as a “special arrangement.” The phrase intrigued him, suggesting a deeper story behind the sisters’ visit.

The breakthrough came when Marcus discovered records from the Lexington Colored Orphan Asylum, revealing that on October 15, 1899, Hannah and Grace had inquired about their younger brother, Thomas, who had been placed in the asylum. What had happened to Thomas? Why were the sisters searching for him?

To understand the sisters’ plight, Marcus needed to learn about Kentucky’s apprenticeship system in the 1890s, which he explored with Dr. Angela Roberts, a historian specializing in post-Civil War labor practices. She explained that the apprenticeship system allowed courts to declare Black children orphans, even if their parents were alive, and then bind them to white families for labor. This system perpetuated a form of slavery that differed only in name.

As Marcus pored over the records, he found that Hannah and Grace had been forced into indentured servitude after their father died, leaving them with debts they could not pay. The judge had given them a choice: jail or indenture. They had chosen the latter, signing contracts that bound them to work for a local tobacco merchant’s family, the Prestons, for five years. The circumstances surrounding their lives were grim, and it became clear why Grace had felt the need to carry a weapon.

Marcus’s investigation took a darker turn when he learned about Grace’s tragic death. A newspaper article reported that she had “fallen from a second story window” while working in the Preston household. But the passive language of the article raised alarms in Marcus’s mind. He discovered a police complaint filed by Hannah, alleging that Grace had been attacked by Robert Preston, the head of the household, before her death. The police dismissed her claims, citing her “questionable moral character” while protecting Preston, a respected businessman.

The horror of the situation settled heavily on Marcus. Grace had carried that weapon because she understood the dangers she faced in a world that offered her no protection. When she had used it to defend herself, she had been murdered, and the system had shielded her killer.

Determined to honor Grace’s memory, Marcus sought to understand more about Hannah’s life after her sister’s death. He discovered that Hannah had been forced to complete her indenture despite the tragedy, enduring years of servitude under the very man who had caused her sister’s death. The psychological toll of serving her sister’s murderer was unimaginable.

Through his research, Marcus found a glimmer of hope. He traced Hannah to Cincinnati, where she had escaped to freedom and found work in a factory. In a letter to a Quaker organization, she wrote about her determination to live and honor Grace’s memory, expressing her desire for a copy of the photograph taken by Hartwell. It was a poignant reminder of her sister’s dignity and strength.

As Marcus compiled his findings, he prepared an exhibition titled Hidden Defenses: Resistance and Survival in the Post-Emancipation South. The centerpiece was the photograph of Hannah and Grace, showcasing Grace’s concealed weapon as a symbol of their struggle for survival. The exhibition aimed to shed light on the hidden histories of Black women in the late 19th century, revealing their resilience in the face of systemic oppression.

The exhibition traveled to various museums, sparking conversations about the historical injustices faced by Black Americans. Marcus received heartfelt messages from descendants of those who had endured similar experiences, sharing family stories that had been passed down through generations. One of the most touching emails came from Joyce Miller, whose grandmother had known Hannah personally. Joyce’s family had always spoken of Hannah’s courage and her dedication to helping others escape difficult situations.

In June 2022, a memorial marker was placed in Lexington Cemetery, honoring Grace’s life and the struggles she faced. The inscription read: “Grace, approximately 1881-1899. Domestic worker, sister, and victim of violence. She carried a weapon to protect herself in a world that offered her no protection.” This tribute served as a powerful reminder of the hidden truths that persisted despite efforts to erase them.

For Marcus, the photograph represented the culmination of his life’s work—uncovering the hidden stories of those who had fought against oppression. It was a testament to the strength and resilience of women like Hannah and Grace, who had navigated a world filled with danger and injustice.

As he looked at the photograph, he saw not just two young women from 1899, but the enduring spirit of all those who had resisted, survived, and fought for justice. Their story, now documented and shared, would serve as a beacon of hope and a reminder that even in the darkest times, the truth could emerge, shining a light on the resilience of the human spirit.