Emergency Alert: Zadarius Smith’s Sudden Retirement Plunges Eagles into Edge Rusher Crisis
Emergency Alert: Zadarius Smith’s Sudden Retirement Plunges Eagles into Edge Rusher Crisis
The Philadelphia Eagles faced a shock to their defensive core with the abrupt retirement announcement of defensive end Zadarius Smith. The veteran pass rusher, who joined the team after Week 1 and was playing effectively (performing as one of the best defensive players in the recent Denver game), gave no indication of his plans, leaving the Eagles’ already thin edge rusher room in a state of emergency.
The departure highlights a major depth problem for General Manager Howie Roseman, as the team is now relying on career special teamers and young, unproven talent.
The Edge Rusher Black Hole
Zadarius Smith’s retirement leaves the Eagles drastically thin at a critical position. The current situation:
Injured Reserve: Nolan Smith (likely out until after the bye-week, and his effectiveness is uncertain due to a lingering triceps injury) and Okaronu (IR).
Retired: Zadarius Smith.
Current Roster (Healthy): Jay Hunt, Joshua Uch, Aziz Ojelari, and Patrick Johnson.
The Concern: Patrick Johnson, who just recorded his first career sack in 51 games, is currently the sack leader among edge rushers but is primarily a special teamer. Veterans like Ojelari and Uch had to fight just to make the roster.
The analysts agreed that keeping the position stocked has been a glaring weakness for the Eagles, and the team now needs to aggressively pursue outside help.
Potential Trade Targets for Howie Roseman
Given the urgency and the need for a significant role player, the Eagles must look to the trade market.
Top-Tier, Problem-Solving Options:
These players would require a hefty price but could immediately solve the crisis:
Trey Hendrickson (Cincinnati Bengals): Considered the name that would “solve the problem.” Hendrickson is an elite player who can get off the passer and set the edge, though the Bengals would be reluctant to trade him. He would immediately be the top guy in the Eagles’ rotation.
Kavon Thibodeaux (New York Giants): A high-pedigree player who is only 24. While the Giants have a surplus of defensive linemen, a trade within the division is highly unlikely unless they feel they are far ahead of the Eagles.
Realistic & Intriguing Options (Miami Dolphins):
The Miami Dolphins, who are struggling, have two intriguing names who could be available:
Bradley Chubb (Miami Dolphins): An older (29), but productive player with four sacks this year. He missed the entire 2024 season with an injury.
Jaelan Phillips (Miami Dolphins): A younger player (25-26) with flash and the ability to contribute 6-10 sacks per season when healthy, despite dealing with some injuries. The question of familiarity with Defensive Coordinator Vic Fangio (who was in Miami) is a factor, but analysts believe he should be looking to acquire either of these players.
Temporary & Internal Solutions:
Brandon Graham (Retired): While many fans will call for the recently retired BG to return, the analysts agree it’s a “better idea in theory than in practice.” Graham hasn’t played or practiced since February, is coming off an injury, and attempting to return in mid-season would be unfair to both him and the team.
Inside Linebackers: The team could consider moving inside linebackers Zack Baun or Jiad Campbell to a limited-snap edge rusher role, especially with Nakobe Dean returning. Both players are versatile and have experience, making them a viable, temporary “duct tape” fix.
The consensus is clear: The Eagles cannot wait for a permanent fix and Howie Roseman must act fast, even if it means sacrificing more draft picks, to salvage a position that is currently putting the entire defense at risk.
