Jon Stewart “Can’t F**king Believe” Democrats Caved on the Shutdown
🤡 Democrats Snatch Defeat from the Jaws of Victory: The Shutdown Capitulation
The segment is a scathing, disbelief-laden critique of the Democratic Party’s capitulation on the government shutdown, which they had initiated and prolonged to demand the extension of Affordable Care Act (ACA) tax credits. Despite having electoral momentum and clear leverage, the Democrats ultimately caved, accepting only a promise for a future, non-binding Senate vote instead of securing their core demand.
The Betrayal: A Fight Given Away
The core issue was the impending expiration of enhanced ACA tax credits, which, if allowed to lapse, would significantly increase healthcare premiums for millions of Americans. Senate Democrats, led by Charles Schumer, were highly vocal, stating the party would “not back down” and was “on the right side of this fight.”
However, a deal was struck by a group of eight Democratic senators (including Tim Kaine and Jeanne Shaheen) and an Independent, who voted with Republicans to advance a short-term funding bill, ending the long-running government shutdown.
The Cost of the Deal: The Democrats gained no extension of the ACA subsidies. Instead, they received only a “promise to vote on it at a later date” in the Senate.
The Squandered Leverage: The critique highlights the absurdity of this trade, pointing out that the Democrats had just achieved their best election night results in years and had the country’s attention focused on the shutdown’s devastating real-world effects, like cuts to food stamps (SNAP) and air travel chaos.
The Empty Promise: The promise of a future vote is mocked as meaningless, as Democrats do not control the Senate or the House. Even if a bill passed the Senate, the Republican-controlled House Speaker, Mike Johnson, has repeatedly refused to bring the subsidies extension up for a vote.
Senator Jeanne Shaheen, who had previously used the plight of a constituent saved by the ACA to underscore the moral necessity of the fight, is singled out for her “cowardice” when she then used the general desire for “bipartisan cooperation” as a cover for her “yes” vote—a move interpreted as doing exactly what the Republicans wanted, which is not “working together” but total surrender.
Schumer’s Political Artifice
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer is accused of engaging in political artifice. He ultimately voted against the short-term funding measure but is suspected of working behind the scenes to allow the eight moderate senators to break ranks. This move would allow the government to reopen (ending the pain that was starting to look bad for Democrats) while protecting himself and other vulnerable Democrats by letting them cast a “no” vote for their progressive base.
Trump’s Distraction and the Giants Analogy
The timing of the capitulation is deemed a “world-class collapse” because the shutdown was finally exposing the gap between Donald Trump’s “reality distortion” and the actual, painful day-to-day reality for Americans. The segment notes that for the first time, Trump’s typical distractions and bald-faced lies—like claiming “we have no inflation”—weren’t working, evidenced by him being loudly booed by football fans while swearing in troops.
The Democrats’ failure to press this advantage is compared to the New York Football Giants, who repeatedly “blow games” with a 95% to 99% chance of winning, emphasizing the sheer ineptitude and self-sabotage by Democratic leadership.
